The boys of 1D battle for king in the Hits 1 Pop Prom semi-finals

Sorry, 1D fans: You can only go in one direction.

The boy band’s four remaining members (it’s a hiatus, not a breakup) Harry Styles, Liam Payne, Louis Tomlinson and Niall Horan all made it to the 2017 Hits 1 Pop Prom semifinals. Sadly, only one can become king, and the guys are sure to split the vote this round.

As the prom queen? Camila Cabello faces Little Mix — narrowly avoiding a competition with Fifth Harmony, which would have been awkward — and Ariana Grande squares off against Selena Gomez.

Make this week’s picks below, and hear all your favorite artists on SiriusXM Hits 1 (Ch. 2).